Amato's Wood Fire Pizza Italian

905 West Main Street, Mount Joy, 17552, United States Of America

🛍 Pizza, Italian, American, North American

3.9 💬 1165 Reviews

Phone: +17176536181

Address: 905 West Main Street, Mount Joy, 17552, United States Of America

City: Mount Joy

Dishes: 18

Reviews: 1165

Website: https://www.amatoswoodfirepizzamenu.com/

"This place was AMAZING. I have a friend here for lunch a few days ago and we have so much food and I have no single complaint about any food we got for us and 4 children. Everything tasted phenomenal. Super hot and fresh, very tasty. Had a wonderful server standing on it in every way. Place wasn't dead, but not insane, where we had to wait for our food for a long time. Only all 6 of our meals come to us about 10 minutes. Will Def come back again and again"


Address

Show Map

Devan Devan

Our first visit and overall it was a great experience. The food and service was excellent!

Menu - 18 options

All prices are estimates.

Reviews

Leann
Leann

We finally tried to try Amato's. We have their wood-fired pizzas (yes it's a real wood stove... no gas) and we were impressed REALLY. For us the pizzas were comparable to LUCA in Lancaster City (seriously). I can't talk to the rest of their menu, but as far as the pizzas go... we'll be back!


Jakayla
Jakayla

I had a great first experience here. I have the chicken Alfredo. The sauce was good and the portion size was good. The next day even had some to eat. My grandmother got the chicken parmigiana, which was also delicious. The only thing they needed was more sauce. My family always liked a lot of sauce. We also had a local taste voucher where you spend $15 and get $30. That's worth it.


Bette
Bette

This place was AMAZING. I have a friend here for lunch a few days ago and we have so much food and I have no single complaint about any food we got for us and 4 children. Everything tasted phenomenal. Super hot and fresh, very tasty. Had a wonderful server standing on it in every way. Place wasn't dead, but not insane, where we had to wait for our food for a long time. Only all 6 of our meals come to us about 10 minutes. Will Def come back again and again

Categories

  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
  • Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!
  • American Enjoy classic American flavors with our diverse menu, featuring juicy burgers, crispy fried chicken, hearty BBQ ribs, and fresh salads. Indulge in timeless comfort with each bite, crafted to satisfy all tastes.
  • North American Savor the diverse flavors of North America with dishes ranging from juicy burgers and crispy fried chicken to tangy BBQ ribs and fresh salads, all capturing the essence of regional favorites and comfort classics.

Amenities

  • Wifi
  • Menu
  • Lunch
  • Dinner

Similar Restaurants

Gus's Keystone Family

Gus's Keystone Family

1050 West Main Street, Mount Joy, 17552, United States Of America

Greek • Seafood • American • Breakfast


"Gus’s is my favorite place to eat. Whenever it is my turn to pick where to go, here is where I pick. However I went by myself yesterday and it was horrible. Worst of all, no one cared. It was a very bad experience for me. The food tasted great and it came out in a decent time frame. However the silverware was dirty and the service was terrible. The waitress told me they had brussel sprouts but she was wrong and just brought me mixed vegetables that I did not order nor want. She never came back to see if things were good and my water was empty the entire time. I wanted a to go order which was a huge issue and I had to ask for the check which I was overcharged. Overall she was the worst waitress I ever had at Gus’s. When I went to leave I told Kelly that the food was good but the service was lousy. Instead of her asking what happened she became argumentative and said that I had one of their best servers. She then gave my credit card to a young man and walked off. So she also gave me bad customer service. Yvette left who was one of their best servers thank goodness Becky is still there. If I go back I will request Beckys area because she always gives excellent service and in return I give her an excellent tip. I tried to call and talk to someone about my experience and was told that besides Kelly everyone was in Greece till the end of July. Shame on Gus’s for treating a customer who has been loyal for years. Like a bother and as if I did something wrong. Good food, terrible customer service !"

Cameron Estate Inn

Cameron Estate Inn

1855 Mansion Ln, Mount Joy, USA, United States

Wine • Cakes • Seafood • American


"These are some of the photos from what we experienced at Easter Dinner. Our server told us she had to be reminded as she forgets a lot. Drinks weren’t refilled, they ran out of dessert and when asked they added a snickers pie that was dug up quickly to put something out. When I called to speak to a person in charge 2 days later, I was transferred to Emily Good’s voicemail, I called back and GM Larry took the call. This was the same GM that was in a chef coat slicing meat and did not clean, refresh or manage the dining properly the day of Easter, BUT decided to hang up on me when I rebutted everything about our experience. I am not sure what is happening with Mgt here or how they got to this point, but it will go downhill really fast.Edit: to your reply. Where was I to go with my guests after 3:30 on an Easter Sunday to feed them. After your reviews online, we decided this would be a very nice place. Unfortunately, after having a wedding the evening before and all your staff being exhausted and talking about it to us, was no excuse for the dining experience we had. We did eat, meagerly as there was not much to choose from. Not one person left with a full belly. As for a refund, a compensation should’ve been given without ever mentioning anything. We were served like peasants with leftovers for when we had expected a fine dining experience. I’m still waiting for Judy to return my phone call."