Explore restaurant menus in Mattituck

Cj's American Grill

➤ 10095 Main Rd, 11952, Mattituck, United States

Seafood • American • Sandwiches • North American

---

"Disappointing. Based on prior reviews we thought the food would be really good. The seafood bisque was extremely salty rendering it nearly inedible. My Reuben sandwich was not too bad but my wife's grilled chicken sandwich was extremely bland. The saucethat came with the sweet potato fries tasted like it was made with pancake syrup and tasted weird. I can only recommend thetater tots I had plus the bread. Service was excellent."

Love Lane Kitchen

➤ 240 Love Lane, Mattituck, New York, USA, 11952, United States

Cafés • Kitchen • American • Breakfast

---

"I enjoyed brunch at this restaurant so much that I went back twice. It's a great spot for people of all ages, with local artwork adorning the walls and a good selection of coffee. I tried the steak and eggs one day and the hash the next, both of which were delicious. The steak had a sweet marinade that made it especially tasty."

A Mano

➤ 13550 Main Rd, Mattituck, United States

Pizza • Cafés • Seafood • Italian

---

"Yikes. Certainly overrated. Unsure why so many stars. Food and service was not good at all, let?s start with the table cube bread? Hard as a rock, tasteless with no side like butter or any oil etc, just dry, hard bread. We ordered ginger ale soda and a sangria. it was house soda, it tasted like bleach water? The sangria was extremely strong and mix was horrible and gave me a stomachache. We left both drinks full on the table. We also ordered the meat ball starter, it was served on soggy bread like a slider. Meatball had no seasoning whatsoever, it had the texture of mush baby food. In terms of the service, forget it. When we first sat down, we waited 15 min for the waiter to bring us water and take our drinks order. The drinks too another 15min to get to us and when they finally arrived, the waiter spilled it on the table and some got on my clothe?a minimal apology came with this mistake. After waiting about 15 mins, we decided to ask for a check and leave. To summarize, $35 we received dog food service. This is NOT Italian cuisine. I hope management see this and learn from it. I don?t write bad reviews but when I do, It had to be something serious. Zero stars. ??"

Michelangelo Pizzeria

➤ 10095 Main Rd, Mattituck, USA, United States

Pizza • Cafés • Seafood • Italian

---

"5/4/22 only back from florida, we had to bring a few things out of the local market and dinner. we chose the Mattituck market and michaelangelo pizzeria next door. we enjoyed a wonderful meal that a meeresfruit pasta, the hubby very enjoyed. it included a lot of seafood, among them moaning, garnel and a lobster dick! one of the specials offered this evening was a pork jelly milanese with a wonderful salat above. the black was juicy, tender and tasteful we enjoyed our dinner and left us to live in the east end. it was great that brenda and our server alicia could not have been more attentive."

Jan's Chinese Food

➤ 10095 Main Rd, Mattituck I-11952-1658, United States

Asian • Seafood • Chinese • Fast Food

---

"I first asked about the pig and dump soup from her online menu and the checkout had no idea what I was talking about.... Certainly the confusion could have been my bad one. I ordered the Sesam chicken plate and it was very good. The restaurant was warm and welcoming, while most Chinese takeout spots have this inconvenient mood with faded characters, worn decor and an inexplicable design."

Pace's Dockside

➤ 2255 Wickham Ave Mattituck, NY 11952, United States

Pizza • Cafés • Steak • Seafood

---

"This is a great spot, perfect for enjoying a nice summer evening. Our food was very good, except for the notable exception of the grilled pizza. With no kids menu, and not many kids friendly options, we went with that for them, and as someone who makes grilled pizza all the time at home, I know how good it can be. This was not. Using fresh tomatoes made for a VERY soggy pizza that I didn't blame the kids for not wanting to eat. Thankfully their bread is delicious and they brought us extra so the kids didn't starve. But I would highly suggest they make some fresh sauce, simmer it down and THEN make the pizza to hopefully avoid the soggy mess we had on our table. Otherwise, the food was good, our waitress was incredibly nice, she offered to bring a side of fries out for the kids, and I really loved the atmosphere!!"

The North Fork Roadhouse

➤ 9095 Sound Ave, Mattituck, USA, United States

Bbq • Pubs • Cafés • American

---

"I'm going to tell you exactly what to expect when you come here. I've been here a handful of times and my experience has been consistent. The food here is excellent and is reasonably priced. We love the chili appetizer and pulled pork and brisket sandwiches. The drink selection is awesome and they mix the drinks nice and strong. You might arrive here first wondering if it will be a good experience because it will probably take a little while to seat you and the service may not be as fast as you expect. But relax. Part of the experience and atmosphere is just sitting back and enjoying your company. If you have little ones and it's warm enough, they have a large outdoor area for them to run around. And they sometimes have a good children's band there to keep them entertained. My children love coming here and that is saying something."

Tony's Fusion North

➤ 9650 Main Rd, 11948, Mattituck, United States

Asian • Fusion • Chinese • Fast Food

---

"The food is back to what it used to be- TASTING GREAT. Though the prices are high and portions moderate, the food is perfection! Honestly it has been a while since I could comment on how great the food is!!! Cheers to whoever is cooking!"

Mcdonald's

➤ 8850 Main Rd Ny 25, 11952 Mattituck, United States

Cafés • Burgers • Chicken • Fast Food

---

"Great service. Run very well. The food was good. Always love McDonald's Big Breakfast. Nice building for McDonald's!"

Iron Skillet

➤ 730 Love Ln, Mattituck, United States

Pizza • Seafood • American • North American

---

"Went here with another couple on a last Friday night and as always, Bob greeted us and made us feel at home. Two of us ordered the lamb frame that was amazing and perfect. One of our friends ordered the NY Strip, which was also made perfect. Another one ordered the meat pig and she said it was just like her mother used to do. We've been here several times, and they never failed to fall on any front. The underlined Iron Skillet is a NOFO dinner and its BYOB policy is a big plus."

Lombardi's Love Lane Market

➤ 170 Love Ln, Mattituck, USA, United States

Cafés • Pizza • Italian • Ice Cream

---

"My husband and I can't say enough AMAZING things about Lauren and her team!! For our 8/12/23 wedding, we worked with Lauren and Emily, and I just have to say they are the best in the business! My husband and I got married at a private estate in Mattituck right down the road from Love Lane Market. She also catered our florist's wedding at the same venue, so we knew right away she was the one for us! First of all, our food tasting with her was unreal! She invited us to her market, and we had a feast! Not only is Lauren the sweetest, but her food is so delicious, and the presentation is stunning! Throughout the entire planning process, her and Emily were on it. They were so responsive to emails/texts and made sure that we had all the rentals we needed, and that the menu was exactly what we wanted. They even went to Magic Fountain for our ice cream bar as we requested! To this day, we are still receiving compliments on the food. Everything from cocktail hour to dinner to dessert, I still can't believe they made everything under a cook tent! Due to the layout of our venue, it was a concern that maybe the food during cocktail hour would not be at the right temperature by the time it would be served, but Lauren and her team came up with a solution and everything worked out! Her entire team was amazing from the bartenders to the wait staff. We honestly can't thank them enough for everything they did. Our wedding day would not have been possible without them. Book them ASAP!!"

Windamere

➤ 2255 Wickham Ave, 11952, Mattituck, US, United States

Pizza • Cafés • Seafood • American

---

"beautiful place, friendly service, live music. there are the 3 stars. Eating was just ok. hit or miss. the menu is very small. party of 4. the hummer cobb was great, but small. the shrimp sampling was good, but I thought it had much too much garlic and lemon. the burgers and truffles were great. the rock steak was terrible. they use the strangest dry rub season I've ever tasted. forget that it was raw when it was served, the taste was like burned hair. I didn't kill you. you need a new cook. anyone who does this without trying it is in the wrong business. this place is not worth the high prices. will not be back."

Cj's American Grill

➤ 10095 Main Rd, Mattituck, United States Of America

Soup • Fish • Meat • American

---

"No outdoor dining available. So, if you a have a dog with you forget this place. Even though an older review states that they have out door dining available. They do not."

Mattitaco

➤ 10560 Main Rd, Mattituck, USA, 11952, United States

Cafés • Seafood • Mexican • Fast Food

---

"I eaten here about 2 weeks ago and it was my second time having it. I kept forgetting to post about it. The food is GREAT. Food is cooked fresh. Awesome seating area and bar tops to eat for lunch. Place is First Responder friendly and will definitely be my lunch spot when I’m in the mood for tacos on the North Fork."

Rose Hill Tasting Room

➤ 2000 Oregon Rd, 11952, Mattituck, United States

Wine • Dining

---

"We love Rose Hill. We’ve gone two time now and both experiences have been amazing. It’s our new favorite winery to visit and we are planning to book one of their rooms in the Inn. The 2020 Riesling is my favorite and their small plates are delicious. I highly recommend if you are looking for a place with a laid back, cool atmosphere."

North Fork Doughnut Company

➤ 100 Love Ln, 11952, Mattituck, US, United States

Cafés • Donuts • Coffee • Catering

---

"A Must-Try Donut Experience at North Fork Donut Company (NOFO DOCO)If you're a donut enthusiast like me, then you absolutely must make a visit to the North Fork Donut Company, NOFO DOCO. From the moment I stepped inside, I knew I was in for a treat!First, the freshness of their donuts is unmatched. It's evident that they take extraordinary pride in crafting these delectable delights daily. Compared to other donut shops I've visited, NOFO DOCO's offerings are in a league of their own. Each bite is an explosion of flavor that will leave you wanting more.One of the standout features of NOFO DOCO is their generous portion sizes. These donuts are large, and I mean it! You certainly get your money's worth, and the size alone makes for a satisfying indulgence. Whether you're looking to treat yourself or share with friends and family, their donuts are perfect for any occasion.Now, let's talk about their innovative creations. The option to have cereal on a donut is a stroke of genius. It adds a delightful crunch and an extra layer of flavor that takes the experience to new heights. Among the many enticing choices, I highly recommend trying their Samoa Donut. It combines the classic flavors of caramel, chocolate, and coconut, creating a heavenly combination that will transport your taste buds to paradise.Indulge in the Samoa Donut or explore their other enticing options; you won't be disappointed. NOFO DOCO is a haven for donut lovers, and I can't wait to go back for another mouthwatering treat.Happy donut indulgence!"

Lucia

➤ 13000 Main Rd, 11952, Mattituck, United States

Cafés • Seafood • Mexican • American

---

"I have been to many restaurants, and this one is definitely one of the best. The Pupusas and Quesadillas are incredibly tasty and the atmosphere is fantastic. The only downside is that the restaurant could be bigger, but when the food is this good, who cares? If you are looking for delicious Hispanic cuisine in the North Fork area, I highly recommend this place!"

East On Main

➤ 10560 Main Road, Mattituck, NY 11952, United States

Pizza • Seafood • American • Fast Food

---

"We had a party for about 50 people. Stephanie, Tony, and their team made a meaningful party special for all who attended. Their communication throughout the planning was always very clear and timely. We arrived to a warm welcome and were taken care of from start to finish by a professional, caring, and fun team. We didn’t hear any complaints from the guests, only joy and gratitude. The East on Main team made it so there were no concerns, only a good time with delicious food and drinks.I recommend this place for not only dinner but to hold an event. I look forward to the next party at East on Main."

Magic Fountain

➤ 9825 Main Rd, Mattituck, New York, USA, 11952, United States

Cafés • Coffee • Ice Cream • Chocolate

---

"Magic Fountain is a spacious ice cream shop that has introduced a variety of almond milk-based ice cream flavors. Typically, they offer at least one excellent fruit flavor, a delicious coffee almond fudge flavor, and a rotating third flavor. They also have a wide selection of sorbet flavors. One of the most exciting offerings is their almond milk shakes, which are hard to find elsewhere! The staff is exceptionally friendly, and they provide convenient curbside pickup during the pandemic. I highly recommend this place!"

Goodfood

➤ 535 Pike St, Mattituck, New York, USA, 11952, United States

Cafés • Pizza • American • Vegetarian

---

"This restaurant is a cozy spot with a friendly atmosphere, offering quick and attentive service for breakfast and lunch. The communal table indoor seating is perfect for meeting new people, while the outdoor two-tops provide a nice option for enjoying the weather. They have nut milk options available, as well as prepared food and a small selection of grocery items like chips, popcorn, olive oil, pickled items, tea, and coffee. Don't miss their amazing selection of empanadas, such as pulled pork and fresh mango, as well as delicious baked goods like the walnut torte. They even have high chairs available for little ones at the communal table, complete with a coloring book and crayons for entertainment."