"If you really appreciate Italian, Billy?s it is. Small and cozy on the main St in Old Forge, Billy?s could compete with the best of them! I usually calculate Italian from the sauce and meatballs, I have to say both were excellent! Other ducks, chicken parm, manicotti and vodka Riggies were also excellent. The atmosphere was like sitting on a Sunday at your mother-in-law, we loved it! Did?t really have high expectations for a tourist city, but Billy?s is the real deal! Reservations are a must, the dining area is small. Not even looking at the competition in the city, that's it!"