Cold Seafood Sampler
Cooper Street Neighborhood Grille

Cooper Street Neighborhood Grille

217 E Main St, Babylon, NY 11702, Village of Babylon, United States

Soup • Fish • Seafood • American


"First time here. Came after work for dinner. Seated Immediately. However the server took almost fifteen minutes to come over to take drink orders. We sat so long we decided to order everything at once just in case. Also he never gave us his name. Drinks: pellegrino in the bottle for me and my husband had cranberry juice. Appetizers: baked clams casino and buffalo wings and New England Clam Chowder. Entree: Maine Lobster Roll for me and Shrimp Penne a la vodka for him Atmosphere: not busy at all, just slow as heck Music: playing Overhead, not loud with a nice playlist Clams had a funky smell. Couldn’t bring myself to eat them. Asked for New England Clam Chowder but as you can see he brought out Manhattan. The waitress asked if she could remove the dishes when she brought the food. She said oh you didn’t like the soup? You barely touched it. I said I didn’t order that but it’s ok. She said you want to take it home? I declined. She asked my husband if he wanted to take his frozen slimey salad home. My husband said no ma’am I’m good. Moments later she brought out our main dishes. The shrimp penne a la vodka was chewy according to my husband. He Said it was undercooked and tasted like glue. My food was served on a burnt roll. Sorry I’ve never had a burnt lobster roll. I tried to stomach the meat only. It wasn’t that bad. It was edible with a Scrooge face to match. The best thing about this dining experience was the pellegrino bottled water and the lovely woman who brought the food and asked us to come again when we were leaving. Other than that, two stars. One for the water and one for her! We will not be back unfortunately. I’ve been dining in the town lately and this was by far the worst experience. By the way, according to our receipt our waiter’s name was Bob. UPDATE: I spent the night vomiting. Arrived home about 15 minutes after we left the restaurant. Became ill within minutes of driving. I ran straight to the bathroom when I got in. NEVER EVER AGAIN!!!!"