"My husband and I came here for NYE and were pretty disappointed by the food and the level of service. There was a pre-fix menu that evening, but we came earlier in the evening before it began, which was fine, however the menu that was being offered instead was extremely limited, and there was a lot of confusion between our waiter and the kitchen about what was being offered at that time. We enjoyed our charcuterie board, but the waiter could hardly say what was on it when we asked and we also had to request appetizer plates. My husband had a flatbread that was so small and drowned in cheese, my shrimp scampi was generally pretty salty, and had bites here and there that were extremely salty, so much so that I was thirsty for the rest of the evening and even got up for a glass in the middle of the night. I just assumed it was how the dish was supposed to be at first, but somebody must have spilled the salt into the dish because I have never experienced such bizarre thirst after a meal before. On any other night the Commons Club might be ok, but the staff seemed pre-occupied with the coming rush of NYE guests that we didn't feel that we received the same standard of service as other guests."
