Pizza • Cafés • Italian • Pizzeria
"Old location was so nice : new location is takeout only basically. Also I'd only recommend pickup, not ordering in person. The vibe isn't very chill for waiting. I think a takeout pizza place should have some warm slices ready too..."
Pizza • Italian • Fast Food • Vegetarian
"This place just continues to disappoint. Called them to inquire why my order hasn 't arrived after almost an hour and the response was that it will be another 30 minutes and 1.5 hours is Very Normal . No apologies offered. And the 20% tip is charged upfront for terrible service! Very disappointed, Pizza showed up almost two hours after was ordered and was cold and burnt. I called the store to complain and was told they’ll give us a $20 store credit on $100 order. Totally unacceptable from start to finish. Done with Amicis San Mateo."
Pizza • Salads • Italian • Pizzeria
"Ordered a pizza from Amici's for pickup to celebrate Pi Day! I have been eating Amici's pizza for years there is one close by my house so I have grown up..."
Fish • Seafood • Vegetarian • Vegan Options
"I have been coming here with my dad since I was a youngster. One of our favorite restaurants. P&E’s holds a really special place in my heart. The service is always wonderful and friendly, beautiful clean atmosphere, and the food is homemade and always excellent. My only plea is to bring the homemade tabouleh and indian pudding back. The tabouleh paired wonderfully with the hummus salad and it was the best I ever had. At one point it was just never on the menu again. It’s probably been a decade and a half since it’s been on the menu. Pleaseeee bring it back!!!!!"
Pizzeria
Salads • American
Pizza • Casual • Italian • Vegetarian
"Definitely a smaller location but in a very nice area. We happened to be in the area and decided to have dinner here. It was quite busy on a Friday night but we were able to get a table right away. Servers were very nice and food was great. We ordered the breadsticks, a margherita pizza to share and each got a pesto pasta with chicken. Everything was cooked well and tasted great. Honestly had no complaints at all. Would definitely come back to this location."
Meat • Pizza • Italian • Fast Food
"This review is based on a single experience with takeout. The website was easy to use and the payment process was smooth. Despite inaccurate operating hours on Google, a call confirmed our food order was perfect. Everything was prepared and ready for pickup. The staff was skilled and friendly. The food was definitely better than the large chain restaurants in the area. The crust was very nice and the ingredients were of high quality. The prices may have been a bit on the higher side, but it was still good value for money. The restaurant was very clean and visually appealing. Despite Santa Cruz Ave being partially closed, the pickup process was easy. We will definitely be returning."
Pizza • Vegan • Pizzeria • Gluten Free
"Like seriously where do I begin. This place is by far my favorite pizza place!! I wish I lived closer. My family and I ordered a couple of different things and shared so we can try it all out and they didn't miss. We ordered a pepperoni and sausage pizza and that was scrumptious! My littles got their spaghetti and meatball kids plate and substituted the noodle for penne. My other kid got the cheese kids pizza and they both loved it! We also ordered their garlic parm bread for starters and it was soooo good! Their ranch is killer too! The service was on point and we were well taken care of. The cleanliness was to my liking. They allowed my pet inside and didn't hassle me about it. They welcomed us happily. The waitress was amazing and super friendly and knowledgeable about the dishes. We were super pleased with this location and their food. We also tried the location they have in SF and it passed just as this place. I have to say this is a must stop if you find yourself near an Amici's because I've gone to two locations and they didn't miss. We ordered a chicken pesto sandwich to go and that thing was out of this world good! So I assume everything on the menu is good. We ordered 6 different items on the menu and it all passed our standards of presentation, flavor, and taste check. ? Amici's definitely doesn't disappoint. I can't stress this enough you have to try this spot at least once for yourself. I understand we all have different taste buds but this place is worth giving it a shot."
Pizza • Pizzeria • Gluten Free • Pet Friendly
"Looks fine restaurant but I was verbally and physically abused by stronger person then me who was at customer service at 10pm in the night. Next time I go into this place I have to risk with getting beaten by gangster, bouncer looking customer service person. One older guy working saved me from getting beaten . Thanks to him, scary . Everyone visiting should have 911 ready in their phone in case customer service gets angry for no reasons."
Pizzeria • Delivery Services
Pizzeria • Pizza, Italian
