"Didn’t know of this place when we set out on foot from the hotel for dinner. The restaurant we went to first was closed early for a private function. The second couldn’t seat our party of 5 for 3.5 hours. Heard the hostess mention Good Pie to the party in front of me, so we went there. All’s well that ends well. Fantastic all the way around. Everything was delicious: garlic knots, meatballs, Caesar salad (with house-made croutons), cheese pizza, pepperoni pizza, and Brooklyn Quality Meat pizza. Fresh-brewed iced tea in a Mason jar. Great service. Loved it."