Green Pepper Pizza
Puzo's Family

Puzo's Family

4 Garfield Ave, Hawthorne, NJ, 07506, United States

Pizza • Family • Cheese • Italian


"*Buyer Beware* the menus have outdated pricing. No one will tell you until you confront them about the check. This place is old school. Beat up walls, wallpaper coming apart in the doorways. But as far as we could see it 's pretty clean. Yes, it 's a good pour of wine, but the menu says $6 for a glass and then we were charged $9 per glass for an $8 bottle of wine!! My husband 's Blue Moon was supposed to be $5 charged $7. Server literally shrugged and said that the menus were old and they had new pricing. They 're laminated paper reprint them. The calamari was not worth $17. It was super chewy. The sauce was marinara with a tablespoon of red pepper flakes dumped in. Nothing special. The pizza is good, but too thin to hold all the toppings. My husband 's pasta was prepared very al dente and was at least $2 more than what was listed on the menu. Service was very awkward. She didn 't clear all the plates. She only took my empty glasses, not my husbands. Every time she approached the table she asked if everything is ok? and then fled quickly from the table. We didn 't complain about anything until I noticed the large discrepancy with the bill. I didn 't argue, I just said they should update their menus and we paid the bill. I realize that prices have gone up, but that should be shown to your customers before they order. It 's not a pleasant surprise at the end of the meal. We will not be returning."