"We are locals here in St Augustine, so we have enjoyed the BlackFly numerous times. Their menu has changed, but there are still plenty of wonderful dishes to select from. Our party of three adults ordered the Bread Basket, which was good; we also ordered 2 appetizers of the Chili-Lime Shrimp, which are in my opinion THE BEST appetizer on the menu. My husband ordered the Filet, I ordered the Grilled Scallops over butter herb pasta, and my friend ordered the Sweet Tea Pork-chops, followed by a slice of Key Lime pie. EVERYTHING was amazing!! The only improvement we could suggest would have been a more attentive waitstaff. My friends tea glass became empty, we had to flag our waiter down after a long wait; Then the waitstaff forgot to bring out the refilled tea… Later on, our water glasses were empty, again after a long wait, we again had to catch his attention to ask for refills. Which he did refill, but with zero ice. Luke warm water… As far as noise level, this visit was much more enjoyable as compared to our past visit when the noise level was so “Energetic” that our table of 4 could not hear each other… so the evening wasn’t enjoyable. This evening we were pleased with the softness of sound."
