"Jeremiah 's is an unassuming little place decorated in green and orange. But man, it is worth the stop. They sell Italian ice, soft serve ice cream, and several different layers items for that extra kick of crunchy goodness. I was thrilled to see an email from them at the end of my workday today that their Pumpkin Pie Italian ice is back because it 's my absolute favorite thing the pumpkin pie ice layered with the vanilla soft serve and Biscoff cookie butter crumbles legitimately tastes like a piece of pumpkin pie with cool whip thrown into a blender and frozen for awhile (my dream! . This is the best time of year to stop at Jeremiah 's!"