"We eat there pretty much every time my brother is in town. They have my second-favorite wings in the area (I'm really picky about wings, and Floods is my absolute favorite), a really delicious chicken pesto sandwich, and the most amazing pickles. I'm not even a pickle person, but I could eat bowls of those things. I really wish they sold them in a jar! Takeout isn't always the best, though. You really have to eat the food IN the restaurant, otherwise it's kind of soggy. I don't think that's a Sarah Street issue, though. I think that's the case for most takeout bar food. The staff is great. I've never, ever had a bad experience with them, and I've been going there since the late 1900s. :D On one visit when my son was little, my brother mistakenly told him it was safe to eat a pepper that turned out to be SUPER hot. Our waitress RAN all the way to the kitchen to get him a glass of milk and all the way back in record time. I've heard people complain in the past about the noise and the lighting. It's a bar, not really sure what they expect. If you want quiet, though, and if it's a nice day, you can eat out on the patio. They also have an upstairs area that's sometimes quieter (as long as it's not being used for a party, in which case you're better off eating downstairs)."