"This place is so inconsistent. Some days, the pizza is really good. Usually we get the pan pizza, but we've also tried the Buffalo chicken (not good at all), the NW traditional (honestly would be so much better without the weird cream cheese drizzle, and I love cream cheese on pizza), and the deluxe classic (not very impressionable bc I don't even really remember what it tasted like). Like I said, it's inconsistent. Some days the pizza is cooked perfectly, some days it's just undercooked and soggy AF. Sometimes it's burnt to a crisp on the bottom, and undercooked up top. Usually the apps are pretty good, but we've only tried just about all of them once except the fire stix and the cheesy stix which we've tried twice. But in our most recent order, the cheese stix were burnt, and not in the good way like a wood fired pizza would be. The entire bottom was blackened and the top was dry and bitter. The bottom of our pizza was burnt as well. And usually the stix come with marinara sauce, but they STRAIGHT UP served us a side of salsa and thought we wouldn't notice. Like, WHAT?! I feel kind of bad for this review bc the staff is always super nice and this place is relatively quick. But what pains me are the prices. Pizza time is just as fast, tastes pretty good, and is a lot more affordable."
Puyallup
