Old Yellowstone Garage

3275 W. Village Drive, TETON VILLAGE I-83025, United States, TETON VILLAGE

🛍 Bbq, Pizza, Cafés, Italian

3.9 💬 1382 Reviews
Old Yellowstone Garage

Phone: (+1)3072015350

Address: 3275 W. Village Drive, Teton Village I-83025, United States, TETON VILLAGE

City: TETON VILLAGE

Dishes: 9

Reviews: 1382

Website: https://calderahouse.com/eat-drink/&cachebuster=1622717133

"Christmas Eve dinner. I had the Bison tomahawk steak. It was cooked to perfection. Crispy burned edges and rare in the middle. It was served with wild mushrooms, smashed baby potatoes, and three yummy sauces that never touched the bison. The only issue was the pheasant. It was so overly salted no one at the table could eat it. We had to send that back. The other seven meals were very good. The staff was very nice. The hostess was amazing at orchestrating the tables and timing."


Address

Show Map

Delaney Delaney

Fantastic Italian restaurant in the middle of the wilderness of Wyoming. The prices are more aligned with San Francisco but it's totally worth it. The service was fast and friendly. My favorite dish was La dolce Vita which was salmon pizza.

Menu - 9 options

All prices are estimates.

Reviews

User
User

This place is a real gem! Open on Thanksgiving night with regular menu while most establishments are either closed or forces the giant expensive meal. Awesome bar, delicious dishes, and chill modern setting. Great find for vegan and vegetarian too.


User
User

A cozy atmosphere and so good food. We had the Focaccia, Radicchio, Bison stew, Paparadelle and Corzetti and would recommend each of them in a heartbeat. The staff was also friendly and helpful and overall the experience was exactly beyond and beyond our expectations go to dinner so many thanks to OYG for us such a beautiful night!


Dustin
Dustin

Christmas Eve dinner. I had the Bison tomahawk steak. It was cooked to perfection. Crispy burned edges and rare in the middle. It was served with wild mushrooms, smashed baby potatoes, and three yummy sauces that never touched the bison. The only issue was the pheasant. It was so overly salted no one at the table could eat it. We had to send that back. The other seven meals were very good. The staff was very nice. The hostess was amazing at orchestrating the tables and timing.

Categories

  • Bbq Savor the smoky and savory flavors of our barbecue offerings. From tender ribs to juicy briskets, each dish is grilled to perfection with our signature sauces and spices for an authentic BBQ experience.
  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
  • Cafés Charming cafés offering a variety of freshly brewed coffees and teas, along with light snacks, pastries, and desserts. Perfect for a morning pick-me-up or an afternoon treat in a cozy atmosphere.
  • Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!

Amenities

  • Wifi
  • Menu
  • Lunch
  • Dinner

Similar Restaurants

Spur Restaurant Bar

Spur Restaurant Bar

3385 Cody Lane, Teton Village I-83025, United States, TETON VILLAGE

Cafés • American • Fast Food • Vegetarian


"My siblings and I visited The Spur on Sunday, August 13, 2023, and our dining experience was extremely disappointing. We had high expectations for a pleasant evening out, but were left shocked by the poor service we received. Our server, Brandon, was far from impressive right from the beginning. It took him quite some time to even acknowledge our table, and when he finally did take our drink orders, he left the completed drinks sitting on the bar for over 10 minutes. My brother had to fetch our drinks himself as Brandon seemed to be inattentive. When Brandon eventually returned to take our order, he failed to address the drink mishap. I specifically ordered a salad with dressing on the side, but when it was brought to the table by another staff member, it was smothered in dressing. After struggling to get Brandon 's attention, I was finally able to inform him of the mistake. He blamed the kitchen, took the salad away, and promised to bring a new one while mentioning it would be comped. While my family ate, I waited a long time for the correct salad to be brought out by yet another staff member. Meanwhile, my brother was trying to get Brandon 's attention for steak sauce, but once again, Brandon was nowhere to be found. Eventually, after being told by two different employees, the sauce was brought to the table. Throughout our entire meal, Brandon did not check on our table, offer drink refills, or bring the bill. He spent most of his time chatting with another table, ignoring us and his other tables completely. When we left a credit card on the table for a bill we hadn't received, Brandon simply took it without a word. Upon returning with a receipt, he said, 'Have a nice night,' without making eye contact. When my sister requested an itemized bill, she was told by the host that they don't provide them. When we tallied up the bill later, we discovered we were still charged for the salad Brandon said would be removed. Upon expressing our disappointment to the host, we were told Brandon had been in the hospital the previous week. This was no excuse for his poor service that evening. The manager, Kelly, came to address our concerns and apologized, offering us half off our next meal. While we appreciated her efforts, we were hesitant to return and risk receiving poor service again. When we inquired about getting a refund for the salad, Kelly claimed it was not possible as Brandon had already processed the payment. Despite her attempts to rectify the situation, my family has decided we will not be dining at The Spur again. The lack of care shown by Brandon and the inadequate resolution offered by Kelly prove to us that our money would be better spent elsewhere."