Castle Hill Supper Club

Recommended from a friend who is local. We were hoping for a nice old school WI small town supper club and this nailed it. Lots of seating, friendly crowd. Lots of food options, well priced. Shrimp cocktail and fried shrimp and fish. Biscuits. Soup and salad. Family atmosphere. Easy for the kids to find something they liked. They had mini desserts and an ice cream cooler. We will do this again when we are on our way from Madison area to Twin Cities area. Good stopping point.

My girlfriend and I were mid-roadtrip when I called in to ask how late they'd be open. After some friendly bantering, it was decided that they'd still be open by the time we expected to arrive. We showed up to a completely empty parking lot (8:10pm on a Thursday) and patron-free restaurant and realized they probably would've shut down early if not for my phone call. That's some generous WI hospitality. We ordered a pair of classic Up-Nort' cocktails to sip on while we pondered the menu and waited for the food to arrive: a brandy old fashioned and a brandy manhattan. Both were exactly what you'd expect and hope for in a place like this, and I'd recommend both if you know what you're getting i...

Where to even start? I suppose at the beginning. We were headed from our home in Central Wisconsin to Minneapolis for the weekend and thought that rather than the usual Interstate fast food fare, we should have a nice enjoyable meal off the beaten path. My wife does a little research and we found Castle Hill. We looked at their website...Inviting pictures, a seafood buffet, long history of operation. Reservations were strongly suggested, so I made some for 6 pm. We arrived a few minutes before 6. Making reservations was totally pointless, we had to wait in line with everyone else. There was an atmosphere among the staff that they were clearly going through the motions and that giving a ****...