Buffalo Nickel - Menu

AVALON, AVALON, United States

🛍 Pizza, Tapas, Mexican, Pub Kitchen

3.9 💬 1258 Reviews

Phone: +13105101323

Address: Avalon, AVALON, United States

City: AVALON

Dishes: 5

Reviews: 1258

Website: https://www.buffalonickelrestaurants.com

"Great food, great service, allowed my girl and I to split the bill. Had the Catalina plate with the Steak, cheese enchilada, rice and beans. The food was so mouth watering and delicious. My other had a salmon and loved it. IF YOU COME TO CATALINA GO HERE! The server was so polite, we came just before the closing hour and left around dark. We were offered a courtesy ride back to Avalon, but we decline it because we had brought our bikes. So polite that they would offer."


Address

Show Map

Money Money

The pizza was EXCELLENT and a great value (2 large with 4 toppings for $33 which is cheap for Catalina! . I will be back. The best pizza on Catalina Island! As good as it looks!

Menu - 5 options

All prices are estimates.

Reviews

Veronica
Veronica

Food was very good. I ordered a whole fried tilapia fish and a michalada which was very good!!!! Service was great from our server however the eldest server there was rude. I would definitely return however if your on the island for just a few hours I recommend to go the the main part of the island to eat instead because this really took up more than half of our time on the island.


C
C

We walked a short distance from town to the restaurant even though you could have call for a pickup from town. This place had been recommended to us by a local and it was definitely worth the walk. Here you will find a delicious ceviche (fish, shrimp, octopus) anywhere on the island. Add the spicy mango but skip the spicy cucumber. The restaurant was busy and offers indoor/patio seating. A+ service from Ricardo.


Tec
Tec

Great food, great service, allowed my girl and I to split the bill. Had the Catalina plate with the Steak, cheese enchilada, rice and beans. The food was so mouth watering and delicious. My other had a salmon and loved it. IF YOU COME TO CATALINA GO HERE! The server was so polite, we came just before the closing hour and left around dark. We were offered a courtesy ride back to Avalon, but we decline it because we had brought our bikes. So polite that they would offer.

Categories

  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
  • Tapas Enjoy a delightful variety of small, flavorful dishes perfect for sharing, combining traditional and modern influences. Savor each bite as you explore diverse tastes and textures crafted to excite your palate.
  • Mexican Authentic Mexican flavors await you with sizzling fajitas, savory tacos, zesty enchiladas, and fresh guacamole, all crafted with rich, traditional spices and served with vibrant sides. Enjoy a fiesta on your plate!
  • Pub Kitchen Enjoy hearty classics and comforting mains crafted with locally-sourced ingredients. Our pub kitchen offers a range of flavorful dishes, from juicy burgers to savory pies, all designed to complement your favorite brew.

Amenities

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Brunch
  • Seating

Similar Restaurants