Mexitaly - Menu

1170 Haines Road, East York, 17402, United States Of America

★ 4.4 💬 82 Reviews

Address: 1170 Haines Road, East York, 17402, United States Of America

City: East York

Dishes: 35

Reviews: 82

Address

Show Map

Menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates.

Calamari

Crispy calamari rings, lightly seasoned and served with tangy marinara and lemon wedges for a zesty kick.

Greek Salad

A fresh mix of tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, feta cheese, and onions, drizzled with olive oil and sprinkled with oregano.

Caesar Salad

Crisp romaine lettuce, creamy Caesar dressing, parmesan cheese, and crunchy croutons.

Cheese Pizza

Classic cheese pizza with a crispy crust, rich tomato sauce, and melted mozzarella, offering a timeless taste in every bite.

Cheese Fries

Crispy fries topped with melted cheese blend, perfect for snacking or sharing.

Italian Salad

A refreshing mix of crisp greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, and onions, topped with Parmesan and classic Italian dressing.

Pico De Gallo

Fresh salsa with diced tomatoes, onions, cilantro, jalapeño, and lime juice. Perfect for chips or topping dishes.

Jalapeno Poppers

Jalapeno Poppers

Spicy jalapenos stuffed with cheese, breaded, and deep-fried to a crispy, golden perfection.

Garlic Breadsticks

Garlic Breadsticks

Golden, buttery breadsticks infused with aromatic garlic, perfect for dipping or enjoying alone.

Similar Restaurants

Victor's

➤ 554 S. Ogontz Street York, PA 17403, Spring Garden Township, United States

Soup • Beer • Italian • Cocktail

"Last night I took a friend to Victors to celebrate her birthday. We had the absolute best waitress and so they appreciate over and beyond! From wine, warm bread, delicious Caesar salads and delicious Aubergines Parmesan; everything was wonderful and so a pleasant time. Thank you."

Rockfish Public House

Rockfish Public House

➤ 110 North George Street, York, 17401, United States Of America

Cafés • Drinks • Seafood • American

"I 'm always a bit suspect of the service this restaurant delivers. I always seem to have to wait so damn ? long to be served. I don 't know if it 's because I 'm usually by myself. Today the waiter came out within 5 minutes with my water (I 'm sitting outside). Damn near 20 minutes went by...I had to call the restaurant to have them send him out to me. Meanwhile the couple beside be, their waiter had been out at least 4 times...took their order and food delivered! I in turned asked him to send my waiter out. This guy came out and instead of leading with an apology he say, you 're so quiet out here. ?"

Blue Heron

➤ 3320 E Market St, 17402, York, US, United States

Vegan • French • International • Offers Delivery

"So sad! We travel to York at least once a year and have always dined at Blue Heron. This visit was so different. The restaurant no longer serves alcohol, but encourages patrons to bring their own. Servers were prompt and helpful, but the food, once wonderful, was mediocre at best. We will not return."

Revival Social Club

Revival Social Club

➤ 19 N George St, York, Pennsylvania, USA, 17401, United States

Cafés • Fusion • American • Vegetarian

"Last night I attended a wedding catered by Revival Social Club. Cocktail hour: bartenders were friendly and the two signature drinks were well and consistently made. There was never a long line waiting to get the first round of drinks- that 's a pet peeve of mine. The bartenders were professionals that kept the line moving. Butlered snacks were deviled eggs and foccacia. Both excellent. I had more foccacia than I probably should have. Hummus Veggie boards filled the room- everything was fresh and carefully arranged. As a former wedding photographer, I always knew what we were in for judging by the meat and cheese boards during cocktail hour. You can tell the thought that is put into the catering when the bread and veggies are as good as they were. Dinner: The bride and groom wanted stations set up as opposed to a formal seated dinner. This is my preferred style of dining, too, so I loved it! If I say 'tacos and sliders ' you may not immediately think of wedding food, but the mahi mahi tacos and the general tso 's cauliflower are so well prepared that all I heard was rave reviews from all of the guests. All of the servers and the manager had smiles on their faces throughout service, and it never felt rushed or chaotic. Most wedding food is forgettable. This will be memorable. Great job, Revival!"

The First Post

➤ 3691 E Market St, 17402, York, US, United States

Soup • Cheese • Seafood • American

"First time visiting this restaurant. We came with friends who had been there before. Food: my wife and I both got the crab soup which, by itself, is 5 stars. Very creamy, not thick or pasty like typical cream soup base soups. I got the NY strip steak, something I rarely do, but took a chance. Ordered it very, very, rare and it came cooked a little more than I would have liked, but still in the neighborhood of rare. It was very good, the spinach and fingerling potatoes were top notch. My wife got the fish and chips. French fries, not chips, were acceptable but not exceptional. The fish was firm but a bit dry. You can almost see that in the picture. Another in our party got a mushroom ravioli dish which was phenomenal...I tasted it. My friend got the short rib which he said was wonderful but I did not try it. Service: this was lacking. Our server was just fine but I suspect slowed significantly by the kitchen. Our appetizers came staggered...it should not have taken 20 minutes to get soup.(The restaurant was not slammed) She came to the table at one point and apologetically told us the soup would be ready soon. I saw several orders of oysters delivered to other tables but did not see them on the menu anywhere. The two issues that reduced the rating from 5 to 4 stars was the service speed and the dry fish. I would certainly go there again. The prices were appropriate."