My New Joint - Menu

22658 Overseas Highway, Cudjoe Key, 33042, United States Of America

Phone: (+1)3057458880

Address: 22658 Overseas Highway, Cudjoe Key, 33042, United States Of America

City: Cudjoe Key

Dishes: 35

Reviews: 0

Address

Show Map

Menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates.

Empanadas

Savory pastries filled with spiced meat or vegetables, wrapped in a crisp, golden crust.

Key Lime Pie

A classic dessert with a tangy lime filling, creamy texture, and a crisp graham cracker crust.

Steamed Clams

Fresh clams steamed to perfection, served with garlic butter and herbs for a delightful seafood treat.

Chocolate Cake

Rich and moist chocolate cake topped with smooth chocolate icing.

Similar Restaurants

Galley Grill

➤ 24862 Overseas Hwy, Summerland Key, USA, 33042, Monroe County, United States

Grill • Coffee • American • Breakfast

"Good brunch food. I am surprised that they have such an extensive gluten free menu, that is nice to see! The Belgian waffle with strawberries was good, and the steak and mushroom sandwich. I had a traditional egg and bacon plate. Glad we stopped her on our route to key west. Only thing I disliked is having only 1 bathroom stall and it’s outside the restaurant. Vegetarian options: For sure you could have waffles, pancakes, eggs and toast, fruit and they have a granola and yogurt option. Dietary restrictions: They have a full gluten free menu available, I posted a pic of it Parking: Parking in gravel lot out front Kid-friendliness: Waffles and pancakes for kids"

My New Joint

➤ 22658 Overseas Hwy, Cudjoe Key, FL 33042, United States, Key West

Pub • Cheese • Drinks • Chicken

"Here right now for the second day in a row. Wasn't planning on coming here either day tbh but no reservations at LPI were avail. If you look at my reviews, they are sparse and I only write when it's horrible or amazing. The food here is BOMB! Service fine but it was busy. 2nd night (now) service is still ok. Not why we came though...the food is SO good. So much that we wanted to come back a second night and we're leaving in 2 days. We give 10/10 for the Buffalo wings, Parmesan cauliflower, SWORDFISH, salad, brussel sprouts and pretzel. A super nice service bartender named Amanda made night #2 awesome. To the owner: food is 10/10 but your service got a 10 tonight for Amanda engaging with us the way she did. Great example of service that an owner should look for."

Mangrove Mamas

➤ 19991 Overseas Hwy, Summerland Key, United States Of America, 33042, SUMMERLAND KEY

Drinks • Casual • Seafood • American

"Other reviews rave about the food we had a different experience. Not sure what fish we were served, but it wasn't Mahi. It was something quite flat, fishy and slimy couldn't even force our way through half of it. Chips and Queso were just OK and the Shrimp Taco's were almost too salty to eat. Maybe we picked a bad night? Price wasn't bad if the food was good, or even mid. Not sure I'd go again. Service: Take out"

Tonio's Seafood Shack Tiki

Tonio's Seafood Shack Tiki

➤ 25163 Overseas Hwy, Summerland Key, USA, 33042-4627, Monroe County, United States

Soup • Fish • Pasta • Seafood

"Like most of the places in the Keys food was mediocre at best. Happy Hour was a joke with only .50 off drinks-why even bother? Lol. Nice atmosphere, but weak weak drinks bland food. Servers are inattentive until they point out where the tip percentages are in the credit card machine. Just like there non existent happy is hour is non existent service Food: 3"

Broil

➤ 21611 Old State Rd 4a, Cudjoe Key, USA, 33042, United States

Soup • Fish • Coffee • Seafood

"Coming from somebody who grew up in the Tampa area with many great steakhouses, this place has a phenomenal filet. Actually, one of the most flavorful filets I’ve ever had. They beat every steakhouse in South Florida and I’d say Tampa/Orlando for flavor and tenderness. Even the sides were delicious. It was a dinner for 2 deal soup salad starch or veggie and a 5 oz filet for only $65?! Wow! Homemade salad dressings, wonderful presentation and superior service. Loved it."