Poppy Seeds Bagels - Menu

1941 Middle Country Rd, South Setauket, United States Of America

🛍 Bagels, Grocery, European, Catering

4.5 💬 269 Reviews

Phone: (+1)6314671771

Address: 1941 Middle Country Rd, South Setauket, United States Of America

City: South Setauket

Dishes: 35

Reviews: 269

"Pretty disappointing the change in management made this place severely lacking in being noticed to get a bagel after stating several times in front of people I wasn’t being helped. Foods good but current employees are severely lacking compared to the previous owner and team. Shame really."


Address

Show Map

User User

bagels are hard and cheap on cream cheeseHad to wait forever for food

Menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates.

Reviews

M
M

The best breakfast sandwiches and bagels in town. Very fast turn out for how busy they are on the weekends.


Amanda
Amanda

The best, freshest bagels around! Always! I got a bagel at noon one day, and it was still super soft and delicious. They make their sandwiches with love! It's always my go to spot, never disappointed!


User
User

Pretty disappointing the change in management made this place severely lacking in being noticed to get a bagel after stating several times in front of people I wasn’t being helped. Foods good but current employees are severely lacking compared to the previous owner and team. Shame really.

Categories

  • Bagels Freshly baked bagels, crisp on the outside and chewy inside, served plain or with a variety of delightful spreads and toppings to suit every taste and preference. Choose your favorite to start your day right!
  • Grocery Discover an array of fresh produce, artisanal breads, gourmet cheeses, and pantry essentials in our grocery section, perfect for crafting a delightful meal at home or on the go.
  • European
  • Catering Catering services offering a diverse range of delicious and beautifully presented dishes, perfect for any event or gathering. Our menu combines creativity with quality ingredients to delight your guests.

Amenities

  • Delivery
  • Breakfast
  • Television
  • Accepts Credit Cards

Similar Restaurants

Mirabelle And Tavern At The Three Village Inn

Mirabelle And Tavern At The Three Village Inn

The Three Village Inn 150 Main StreetNY 11790, Stony Brook, United States

Cafés • French • Seafood • European


"I was looking forward to trying Mirabelle again after a bad experience we had when they were at their old location years ago. I had friends from out of town in and we were looking for an historical venue to go along with a local revolutionary war event in Setauket and The Three Village Inn fit the bill. Unfortunately, I was unimpressed overall with our experience. The waiter was terrific, no problem there. We asked for the Tavern portion of the restaurant, hoping for that old Colonial Tavern feel, which it partially delivered. It was mostly modern, not a bad thing, but not completely what we had in mind. We had some tasty appetizers. A Charcuterie Board that was good and a Butter Board that was also tasty. The crusty bread they served with it was delicious. We also had the raw oysters; small but good. Had we stopped there for drinks and apps, it might have been a good meal, but we all continued on with our entrees and that where things turned out to be disappointing. Part of the problem is the regular menu is not very interesting and for some reason they had no “Farm to Table” specials on this particular Saturday night. I had the Milanese style Pork Chop with a salad topping, that was tasteless. My wife and one of our friends had the signature Duck. For a French Restaurant we were expecting something delicious. Again, it lacked any kind of flavor other than the chutney that was served with it. It had no sauce, Au Jus, or crispy skin. All in call not, worth ordering again. My friends had the chicken which looked a little better, but no one was raving about it. I don’t know what the rest of the limited menu is like, but nothing else sounded really good. I have heard that the Tavern Burger is good, but for the price, I can get a good burger anywhere. Suffice it to say, this experience is not going to make us run back there any time soon."

Red Tiger Dumpling House

Red Tiger Dumpling House

Red Tiger Dumpling House, 1320 Stony Brook Rd, Stony Brook, NY 11790, USA, United States

Fish • Meat • Seafood • Chicken


"Only went once, so sometimes the first try is great and after that it’s goes all wrong. But the food was nice, there is a small vegan menu (very small). We ordered the pepper steak, it was good. The waiter did have to ask us if we wanted a particular sauce because the sauce was not vegan or vegetarian. I wasn’t sure what it was, but I think it was for extra spicy (not traditional fish sauce, but this sauce did have fish in it). So the waiter did get that this wasn’t vegan and was nice enough to let us know, so we were able to tell them to not add that fishy hot sauce thanks to his warning. We did have the veggie dumplings, the waitress did swear there was not any egg wash only veggies and no dairy. Usually it’s egg wash you have to worry about as per another Asian restaurant mentioned to me once. Although the dumplings were green and it had an ever so slightly sea taste, I believe it was seaweed in the dough, but I wasn’t sure to be honest. But the waiter seem to get we didn’t eat fish and such, he didn’t say this had fish sauce or anything. I tasted the filling alone and it did not taste like the sea. So I’m not sure, just FYI I am 95% sure dumplings are vegan, but not 100% sure. Oh and you do have to order rice or something, these dishes did not come with rice. But it was enough for 2 people to split, maybe three if everyone ordered their own bowl of rice, which is $1 each. I noticed on reviews elsewhere someone complained that they ordered something from the vegan menu and as the customer was picking up the order the staff had warned them that the vegan dish had bacon bits in it. They were confused as to why this dish was even on the vegan menu. So I’m not sure what that was about. But the reviewer didn’t mention which dish that was. I like the atmosphere actually, it seems authentic to me and colorful, but it was cold where we sat, and it’s cash for tips. So I give it 4 stars with vegan caution. It is small too."