Schafer's - PORT JEFFERSON (menu)

Phone: +16314738300

Address: 111 W. Broadway Port Jefferson, NY 11777, 11777-1629, PORT JEFFERSON, United States

Dishes: 35

Reviews: 645

Website: http://www.schafersportjeff.com/

"Went on New Years Eve with my boyfriend for drinks and we went specifically for the dueling pianos. Called earlier in the week and was advised yes they would have the dueling pianos on New Years Eve....also called again that day to make sure they would have the dueling pianos that night and was advised again dueling pianos would be on at 8:00 that night.. Arrived at Schafers at 9:00 sat down at the bar and asked the bartender why the dueling pianos were not on...was advised they would be coming back on shortly and was suggested we order a drink in the meantime....had our drink, ordered some food....1 hour later still no dueling pianos. Questioned another bartender ans was told no., the duel...

Address

Charlene

★ ★

Food- skip it. Really. Don't. I got the vegetarian burger- zero taste. Soggy buns from the get-go, probably from the grilled portabella mushroom. The...

View More Reviews

Menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates.

Prawn

Juicy prawns grilled to perfection, seasoned with garlic and herbs, served with a tangy lemon butter sauce.

Caprese

Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, olive oil, and balsamic glaze.

Calamari

Crispy calamari rings, lightly seasoned and served with tangy marinara and lemon wedges for a zesty kick.

Crab Cakes

Savory and golden crab cakes, crisp outside with tender, sweet crab meat inside, served with a zesty remoulade.

Wedge Salad

Crisp iceberg lettuce topped with bacon, tomatoes, blue cheese dressing, and chives.

Baked Clams

Fresh clams baked with a blend of herbs, garlic, and breadcrumbs, offering a savory, golden crust with a tender interior.

Lobster Roll

Fresh lobster meat tossed in light mayo, nestled in a grilled buttery roll, topped with a hint of lemon and chives.

Buffalo Wings

Spicy and crispy chicken wings served with celery sticks and blue cheese dressing.

Lobster Ravioli

Delicate pasta filled with succulent lobster, served in a rich, creamy sauce with a hint of herbs and garlic.

Chicken Cordon Bleu

Crispy breaded chicken breast stuffed with ham and Swiss cheese, served with a creamy Dijon mustard sauce.

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail

Chilled jumbo shrimp served with tangy cocktail sauce, perfect for a refreshing seafood appetizer.

Reviews

Nicole

★

Wish I could give this place less stars. Wouldn't let us in because my boyfriend has ONE rip in his jeans. I've been down here a bunch of times and never...

Ted

★ ★ ★

We just returned from the Grill. For a Saturday it was pretty empty but we had our own room. 13 of us. A check for over 500. The waitress was good. Our two...

영진

★

Went on New Years Eve with my boyfriend for drinks and we went specifically for the dueling pianos. Called earlier in the week and was advised yes they would have the dueling pianos on New Years Eve....also called again that day to make sure they would have the dueling pianos that night and was advised again dueling pianos would be on at 8:00 that night.. Arrived at Schafers at 9:00 sat down at the bar and asked the bartender why the dueling pianos were not on...was advised they would be coming back on shortly and was suggested we order a drink in the meantime....had our drink, ordered some food....1 hour later still no dueling pianos. Questioned another bartender ans was told no., the dueli...

Amenities

Similar Restaurants

Panera Bread

➤ 4959 Nesconset Hwy, 11776, Port Jefferson Station, United States

Cafés • Pizza • Salads • Seafood

"Literally the worse Panera in the area. I?ve called and complained but at this point they need new management. The manager doesn?t do anything to make you feel compensated in any way. She just makes excuses. From basic things like notifications foronline orders/ rapid pick up and the food itself are always a disappointment or problem. Today I had it, my sandwich wasterrible. Bread was dry and hard. Salad which was a full salad was half way full. Higher management needs to get involved!"

Z Pita

➤ 217 Main StNY 11777, PORT JEFFERSON, United States

Pizza • Cafés • Seafood • Vegetarian

"The restaurant has stunning decor and offers delicious food! The portion sizes are generous, and the staff is incredibly welcoming and friendly. We enjoyed both the Mediterranean (Saganaki Special) and Italian (Chicken Sorrentino) dishes, and they were both outstanding!"

Bagelicicious Cafe

➤ 1031 NY-112, Port Jefferson Station, United States

Cafe • Cafés • Bagels • Coffee

"Lisa and I had a great experience at this restaurant. We made sure our online order was correct and received fast, friendly service. The café was beautifully decorated for the holidays, adding to the nice atmosphere. Overall, it was a wonderful dining experience. Lisa Lichelle."

Pasta Pasta

➤ 234 East Main Street Port Jefferson, NY 11777, 11777-1865, PORT JEFFERSON, United States

Pizza • Cafés • Seafood • Italian

"The food here is amazing. I actually didn’t get the pasta when I went so I can’t say it’s the best pasta on Long Island. I had the lobster pizza and it was absolutely amazing. They also bring out a huge loaf of garlic bread right out of the oven it’s so fluffy and moist and delicious! Some of the best bread I’ve ever had. All their ingredients are quality and everything tastes really fresh. The place is a bit small and the first time I went it was a Saturday and they kinda rudely said you had to have a reservation on Saturdays but the food by far makes up for it."

Fifth Season

➤ 34 East Broadway, 11777, PORT JEFFERSON, United States