Sticky Fingers Delectables

Benji And Jake's

➤ 5 Horseshoe Lake Rd, White Lake I-12749-7721, United States

Pizza • Salad • Italian • American

---

"The food was outrageously good. Their specialty soup was the best! Their burger was big, juicy and very tasty. Even the standard mozzarella sticks had a great cheese pull, so my children said. Would definitely recommend. We did outdoor seating on a Sunday afternoon."

Brother Bruno's Of Monticello

➤ 951 NY-17B, Mongaup Valley, USA, 12762, United States

Soup • Pizza • Pasta • Pizzeria

---

"Idyllic gem deceptively hidden behind seemingly permanent roadside construction. Family owned and operated, and recently relocated from a location in Monticello. Now Brother Bruno's is nestled next to the Mongaup Creek with placid views to the same. Food appetizers, entrées and desserts are exquisite. Waitstaff efficient and friendly. Prices very fair. Facilities well maintained, including clean bathrooms. Full bar upfront. Ample parking in the front. On September 8th,2020 the Sullivan County Libertarian Party hosted Larry Sharpe at this location."

Local Table Tap (the)

➤ 3 Horseshoe Lake Rd, 12749, Kauneonga Lake, United States

Cafés • Pizza • American • North American

---

"My burger was excellent, a five star meal; It was the best I've had in a long while, perfectly cooked, crispy and charred on the outside and juicy on the inside. The spicy pickles here are an interesting touch, the lettuce was crisp and fresh, the tomato perfect. The fries were also absolutely delicious, cut much thinner than I've seen elsewhere. My date's meal was a little less exhilarating; Arugula and roasted mushrooms on grilled cheese sounded good in principle but tasted bitter in practice. The view from the outdoor deck was beautiful. My reason for docking the star however, comes not from the food or view, but from other sources. For example, the palm-sized ball of human hair and dust that blew back and forth between the door and my table for the duration of my meal, chased by concerningly abundant flies which flew in our faces and landed on our food; The speakers played a maddening, endless string of soulless modern reggae songs that sounded like the same single tune stuck on repeat; and the waitress, while efficient and kind to us, seemed to be the only person waiting on every single customer in the place by herself. I watched in dismay as she carried a customer a shot of liquor to a customer between her fingers instead of on a tray (an especially bad idea during COVID-19), an unnoticed stream of spilled drink pouring from the overfilled glass and onto the floor; shortly after, I was further distressed to see her pick up and throw crumbs from one of the tables into the lake, which simply isn't an acceptable food waste receptacle and might explain the flies. If it wasn't for the truly impressive burger these factors would have brought it down to 3.5 or 3 stars."

Sorella

➤ 3562 State Rte 55, White Lake, USA, 12749, United States

Wine • Pizza • Pasta • Italian

---

"Seriously good pizza and friendly service. Bathroom is very clean, makes me confident that the restaurant is kept nicely. Prices are amazing, got a large pie, garlic knots and an italian hero all for $30. Definitely stop here after a long day of boating/swimming."

The Fat Lady Cafe

➤ 13 Horseshoe Lake Rd, Kauneonga Lake, USA, 12749, United States

Cafés • Vegan • American • Farm To Table

---

"I had the kalamari that was melted in your mouth and the hamburgers were tasteful and juicy and full of taste, and the salate was crunchy. it's a must."