Tony's New York Pizza

42 S Antrim Way, Greencastle, USA, 17225, United States

🛍 Soup, Pizza, Italian, Sandwiches

4 💬 2332 Reviews

Phone: +17175972152

Address: 42 S Antrim Way, Greencastle, USA, 17225, United States

City: Greencastle

Dishes: 11

Reviews: 2332

Website: http://tonys-pizza.com/

"This has always been my favorite pizza spot, and I've often been pretty critical about my dining experiences. However, I finally took my dad's advice and stopped calling the place every three minutes, getting frustrated when they didn’t pick up. When I visited in person, I found it packed with customers, and everyone was really friendly—especially the new staff. We had a great conversation about our favorite beach! A big thank you to the owner and the management for creating such a welcoming atmosphere."


Address

Show Map

User User

The food was okay the price kind of Deep and they got to fix the problem with the bugs

Menu - 11 options

All prices are estimates.

Reviews

User
User

The pizza looked fantastic and the kids really enjoyed it. However, I ordered the eggplant dish and found it to have more breading than actual eggplant.


User
User

this place used to be the best pizza when the old man was around. now very little cheese crust very hard on the floor and I h8 to say, but brother pizza has beaten her


User
User

This has always been my favorite pizza spot, and I've often been pretty critical about my dining experiences. However, I finally took my dad's advice and stopped calling the place every three minutes, getting frustrated when they didn’t pick up. When I visited in person, I found it packed with customers, and everyone was really friendly—especially the new staff. We had a great conversation about our favorite beach! A big thank you to the owner and the management for creating such a welcoming atmosphere.

Categories

  • Soup Warm and comforting soups to nourish your soul. Choose from a variety of flavorful broths and hearty ingredients, perfect for a simple appetizer or a satisfying meal on a chilly day.
  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
  • Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!
  • Sandwiches A delightful assortment of freshly made sandwiches, crafted with premium ingredients and served on artisan bread. Perfect for a quick lunch or a satisfying meal, each bite is packed with flavor and goodness.

Amenities

  • Credit
  • Takeout
  • Takeaway
  • Delivery

Similar Restaurants

Putnam Inn

Putnam Inn

400 N Jackson StIN 46135, Greencastle, United States

Cafés • Buffet • Seafood • American


"We've been going to Putnam Inn for a few years, but what a find! We love this place! We never had a bad experience in this food! We took some family members for lunch on Saturday 7/2/16. The buffet changed from breakfast to lunch when we arrived. The lady who sat on us said it was about 10 minutes or so to be completely finished, so that we put our waitress, our beverage orders came. We have drinks in time. The buffet was ready for lunch within the time the lady said it was. I must say all raves about the fried chicken BUT let me say I tried the pox for the first time they were the bomb! I hardly needed a knife to cut it!! I have NIE pork chops in a restaurant, let alone on a buffet that soooo delicate had so good taste! WOW! I have read some mixed reviews about this place, but I can honestly say we never had a bad experience with the food, the staff or the decor of the dining room! The tables are clean, the buffet always seems clean, even the cutlery! Genuine cloth napkins for a buffet?! What a treat! I like the decor. Yeah, it's simple, but I'm here to eat the delicious food, not to decorate ideas. The fancier the facility the more you pay. The price for the buffet is very reasonable given the type of dishes served! Maybe we're not picky people, but I always leave this place with a good feeling! I say if you're starving here, it's your own fault! I wouldn't change anything here!"