Tony’s Pizza - Menu

604 West Historic Mitchell Street, Milwaukee, United States Of America

🛍 Pizza, Pickup, Burgers, Delivery

4.7 💬 82 Reviews

Phone: (+1)4142128465

Address: 604 West Historic Mitchell Street, Milwaukee, United States Of America

City: Milwaukee

Dishes: 22

Reviews: 82

Website: https://www.tonyspizza604.com/

"Unfortunately this pizza didn't live up to the hype. Maybe it has to do with ordering on a holiday (Thanksgiving's Day), but this was our first time/last time ordering here so we'll never know. There was essentially no flavor to the pizzas and we're not even sure there was sauce on them. On a positive note, they were cheesy and the crust was thin and not over cooked. The cheese bread was worthwhile. They were saucy and cheesy and what accounts for one of the stars. The wings had pretty good flavor but were soggy unfortunately. Maybe they're better in the restaurant"


Address

Show Map

Monica Monica

Best pizza place. Love it!

Menu - 22 options

All prices are estimates.

Reviews

Debra
Debra

the garlic parmesan wings were the BEST EVER


Julia
Julia

So good. Seriously some of the best pizza we have ever had.


Jenn
Jenn

Unfortunately this pizza didn't live up to the hype. Maybe it has to do with ordering on a holiday (Thanksgiving's Day), but this was our first time/last time ordering here so we'll never know. There was essentially no flavor to the pizzas and we're not even sure there was sauce on them. On a positive note, they were cheesy and the crust was thin and not over cooked. The cheese bread was worthwhile. They were saucy and cheesy and what accounts for one of the stars. The wings had pretty good flavor but were soggy unfortunately. Maybe they're better in the restaurant

Milwaukee

Milwaukee

Milwaukee is known for its brewing history, vibrant arts scene, and diverse cuisine, including classic German fare, cheese curds, and frozen custard.

Categories

  • Pizza Delve into our perfectly baked pizzas, crafted with hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and a blend of gourmet cheeses. Each slice bursts with fresh toppings, ensuring a delightful bite every time.
  • Pickup Quick and convenient, our Pickup category offers delicious meals prepared with care and ready to go. Perfect for busy days or a cozy meal at home, enjoy a variety of dishes that suit any taste and preference.
  • Burgers Juicy, flavorful burgers crafted with premium ingredients, from classic beef to unique vegetarian options, all served with fresh toppings and a choice of hand-cut fries or a crisp salad.
  • Delivery Enjoy your favorite dishes from the comfort of home. Choose from our extensive menu and get it delivered fresh and fast. Perfect for staying in or treating yourself. Quick, easy, and just a click away!

Similar Restaurants

Five O'Clock Steakhouse

Five O'Clock Steakhouse

2416 W. State St. Milwaukee, WI 53233, United States

Soup • Steak • Venues • Seafood


"let me start from the moment I arrived, until the moment I went, I was treated so well by all the staff. this place has a deep feeling, and that was an experience you can get nowhere else. the host who took our beverage order donna was so incredibly friendly and up to the earth, it felt like making a new girlfriend. the waitress we had (I can't remember her names, but she had dark hair and a fan to make sure she wasn't heated over while serving that I thought was an incredible idea) was exceptional at point and friendly. she made sure we took care of every moment when she noticed something was running low on our table. we were so comfortable with her, we could talk about everything! she was amazing! they start at the bar where they can order a drink and plan their order. Once they have ordered their food, they close their tab at the bar and then they are moved to their edible for their meal. they get a radishes board that includes sweet, pickel, olive and paprika. it was a delicious start and is free with its meal along with brot and salat. my coworker and I ordered both a rib eye. we shared a side of creamy spinat and sparing (the side orders are more than enough to share I did not want my steak rare or medium rare, but in between, and the boil nailed it. the outside of my steaks was perfectly presumed with a delicious crust. the au jus was a bit salty for my pleasure, but it has improved the taste of the steaks. my steak was perfectly boiled where it melted in the mouth with little wall on chew. I almost cried, that was good. I was so incredibly impressed by all the experience, I will be more than happy to make sure that I have this restaurant every time I have to say to wisconsin (I am from ohio but travel to wi for the work the only thing I have to tell the owners are: bravo"