Anderson's Frozen Custard

Phone: (+1)7166815464,(+1)7166918970

Address: 2369 Niagara Falls Blvd West Amherst, NY 14228, United States

Dishes: 35

Reviews: 4852

Website: http://andersonscustard.com/

"Only had soft serve ice cream, so I can't comment on anything else. Small cone was on what I would have considered a baby cone, and quantity was equivalent to that as well. Price was in line with small cone prices at other shops. Quality was very good, but overall I was disappointed. Service was OK. 4 stars is hoping that the food continues to be above average."

Address

Joseph

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

The ice cream cake had a very different and eye catching design! It also tasted very good! My first time buying an ice cream cake from Anderson’s; I’ll definitely be back!

View More Reviews

Menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates.

Sundae

A classic ice cream treat with scoops of vanilla ice cream, topped with rich chocolate syrup, whipped cream, and a cherry on top.

Hot Dog

A classic grilled hot dog served in a soft bun with your choice of toppings including mustard, ketchup, onions, and relish.

Cookies

Freshly baked cookies with a golden crust and soft center, available in classic chocolate chip or oatmeal raisin.

Coleslaw

Crunchy cabbage and crisp carrots mixed with creamy dressing for a refreshing side dish.

Dirt Sundae

Chocolate pudding layered with crushed cookies and gummy worms, creating a fun, playful dessert reminiscent of childhood dirt play.

Banana Split

A classic dessert with a banana, topped with ice cream, whipped cream, and assorted sweet toppings.

Potato Salad

A creamy blend of tender potatoes, fresh herbs, and a tangy dressing, perfect for a light and refreshing side dish.

Baked Potato

A fluffy baked potato topped with creamy butter and chives for a classic, comforting side dish.

Turtle Sundae

A creamy vanilla ice cream topped with rich chocolate sauce, caramel drizzle, and crunchy pecans.

Buffalo Chicken

Spicy buffalo chicken topped with tangy sauce and served with a side of creamy dressing.

Grilled Chicken

Juicy grilled chicken breast seasoned with herbs, served with a side of fresh vegetables.

Chicken Sandwich

Grilled chicken, crispy lettuce, juicy tomatoes, and creamy mayo on a toasted bun.

Create Your Own Sundae

Indulge in a sweet treat by customizing your own sundae with an array of toppings and flavors to choose from.

Reviews

Jen

★ ★ ★ ★

The ice creams are ok. The bubble gum flavor had some gum pieces that are very hard to chew. The Oreo ice cream had tons of cookies which was nice, but the one with pretzels just a couple of pieces and the ice cream didn’t taste like much.

Dee

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Always visit here. They have ice cream and food. Never tried the drive thru. Got a root beer milkshake, this was made with root beer syrup not from the fountain and the Choco Peanut Butter Passion. Lots of indoor and outdoor seating. Multiple registers to place order. Variety of food, drinks and ice cream flavors. Employees are nice and quick.

Brian

★ ★ ★ ★

Only had soft serve ice cream, so I can't comment on anything else. Small cone was on what I would have considered a baby cone, and quantity was equivalent to that as well. Price was in line with small cone prices at other shops. Quality was very good, but overall I was disappointed. Service was OK. 4 stars is hoping that the food continues to be above average.

Amenities

Similar Restaurants

Taichi Bubble Tea

➤ 2309 Eggert Rd, Tonawanda, United States

Tea • Asian • Salads • Japanese

"Friendly workers, relaxing atmosphere, fun games, delicious drink and food... Taichi Bubbletea is hands down my favorite place to relax in Rochester. Your menu is fantastic. I've been going there since they opened in Henrietta. It makes me so proud and happy to see that they have a different location in Irondiquoit! This is definitely a place to visit. If you've never had the bubbles, you might get it on the side or ask for less or no one until you're done!"

Panera Bread

➤ 1593 Niagara Falls Blvd, Amherst, NY 14226, USA, 14228, United States

Seafood • Bakery • European • American

"My daughter and her friend went in and used kiosk to order 4 sip club orders (one each for them and mine and my husbands). There were no cups at the kiosk area so she had to ask the cashier. She was questioned about her sip club order and then she was not allowed the 4 cups that she requested. Only given hers. We pay a lot for 4 sip club subscriptions every month. My daughter was embarrassed and felt singled out because she is 16. Service: Take out Meal type: Other Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1"

Fuji Grill

➤ 736 Maple Road Buffalo, NY 14221, United States

Wine • Sushi • Asian • Japanese

"I gave them a 3 stars because I didn't like the aal not being boned. I could eat it as the bones are small enough, but it was very unpleasant. the gurke was not fresh either. the prices are very reasonable so that this was a good thing."

Giancarlo's

➤ 5110 Main St Ste 125, 14221, Williamsville, United States

Wine • Seafood • Burgers • Steakhouse

"An absolutely amazing experience, from start to finish. To start, we were treated like kings and queens by the entire staff. Atmosphere was classy and modern. Food was to die for, I ordered the Meatball for our appetizer which is covered in their house made red sauce, then for my main course I had the Bone In Ribeye which is a must have with the mashed potatoes for a side. Everything was timed and spaced out perfectly! I will definitely be returning soon, as this is now my favorite Steakhouse in WNY"

Share Kitchen And Room

➤ 5590 Main St, Williamsville I-14221-5412, United States

Tapas • Tacos • American • Vegetarian

"Our server was exceptional! Despite the bustling environment, he provided attentive service, frequently checking in with us, refilling our water glasses, and artfully arranging the plates so that each dish was beautifully presented. The water, infused with lime, was a delightful surprise—extremely refreshing and served as a lovely palate cleanser. We started our meal with the honey garlic bread accompanied by herb ricotta. The bread offered a wonderful balance of flavors, and the ricotta added a creamy touch that complemented it perfectly. Next, we tried the Pad Thai Tacos. While I wasn't a fan of the spice level, I appreciated the creative combination of hard and soft shells, along with the tasty peanut sauce. Then we moved onto the "ball," which is a great example of how the restaurant encourages sharing. Each dish was served with a large knife and serving spoon, making it easy for us to split everything. The flavor was remarkable, especially the sweet sauce paired with the grilled bread. For our main course, we ordered the Chicken Cutlets, which were again served with a knife and tongs for easy sharing. Although I wasn’t fond of the wine sauce, the chicken was perfectly cooked. The meal truly stood out with the two desserts we chose: the butter cake and the orange chocolate crème brûlée. Both desserts struck the ideal balance of sweetness! I highly recommend this restaurant!"