Casey's General Store

Empanadas More

➤ 44 W Main StNY 10940, Middletown, United States

Cafés • Mexican • Spanish • Empanadas

---

"I have tried this restaurant twice and both times even though it has ben a while since I tried ordered they were both good. They haven't changed a bit. They have a clean restaurant, and they make it feel a little modern and feel homie. I ordered the beef and chicken empanadas. The dough or flower not sure how they make them, but they are fresh and didn't taste refried. They have a nice golden color and have an amazing habanero mango salsa to go with them. I would definitely recommend this location to anyone. Keep up the good work at Olivia's."

Tony Boffa's

➤ 75 Railroad Avenue, City Of Middletown, 10940, United States Of America

Pizza • Italian • Pizzeria • Delivery Services

---

"This is the cutest restaurant ever. I came here and was treated like a celebrity. I'm not even kidding, impeccable service. I'm pretty sure it's family owned. I believe the owner was walking around to make sure everyone was good. I specially remember her literally going to each table to personally make sure everyone was okay. You don't see that a lot so it's pretty much unforgettable. To the food: wow. Wow. Let me say it one more time, wow. I really do believe they make this with love because everything I tasted was amazing. I got the shrimp lobster scampi which was in garlic and white wine sauce. So good!!!! It was really filling and seasoned greatly. The restaurant in terms of decor is pretty dated- but I guess that's what makes it super homey. It was PACKED when I went and I see why. I want to come back soon because there is so much on the menu I didn't get to taste. You know when you're sitting waiting for the waiter to bring out your food and you keep looking at the tables around you when they get their food- my mouth watered anytime someone got something regardless of what it was. Everything looked so good. The couple next to me said they have been coming here for years and they never disappoint. I can see why. It's for sure authentic Italian cuisine. Middletown is not a popular town but this place definitely can hold the popularity of it. I wish I remembered my waitress name because she was EPIC. You can tell everyone here takes their job seriously. I loved it."

Saffron Indian Cuisine

➤ 130 Dolson Ave, Middletown, United States Of America

Cafés • Indian • Chicken • Vegetarian

---

"64. Balti Gosht the lamb was overcooked and had more sauce than meat and wasn't as flavorful.76. Garlic Naan was a bit rubbery and didn't have much garlic. They don't give you an adequate amount of meat to rice ratio. They barely added any lamb to both the lamb dishes I ordered and considering the price I expected more for the price I paid for both items. The lamb rice dish was pretty tasty and lamb was cooked well not dry or tough and was well seasoned."

Something Sweet Dessert Cafe

➤ 17 North St, 10940, Middletown, US, United States

Cafés • Vegan • Casual • Desserts

---

"This is the first dine-in restaurant we ate at since the beginning of the pandemic. I ordered the hummus plate and mushroom risotto while my fiance ordered the crab cakes and the scallops. Hummus was great! Crab cakes can use a bit improvement. I was getting pretty full at this point from all the bread... Risotto was good (I had to add salt for a bit more savory flavor) and the scallops were what I expected. The sauce for the scallop was pretty good. Not a bad experience. I would've chosen the hangar steak instead of the risotto. Place is nice to take a date or hang out at. Friendly service as well."

Coney Island Cafe

➤ 10 Railroad Avenue, City Of Middletown, 10940, United States Of America

Cafés • French • Chicken • American

---

"If you're hungry for anything or sing or you got the munchies this is the place I recommend for anybody. They have breakfast all day long till they close and their breakfast is worth diving into I personally have had their Irish eggs Benedict which was absolutely delicious especially with homemade corn beef hash. I have also tried their banana bread French toast which is as delicious and super filling as you believe it is. I've also just snack down on a Coney island dog which is the best hot dog I could recommend getting I've also had their cheeseburgers which are amazing and if you get chicken tenders from there absolutely delicious so good there's nothing like having fresh chicken tenders made for you. Also the vibe in there is very chill it's nice to just walk in there sit down and enjoy yourself they have great atmosphere over there."