Phone: +16314723018
Address: 836 Montauk HwyNY 11705, Bayport, United States
City: Bayport
Dishes: 35
Reviews: 1690
Website: http://www.thefishstoreonline.com/
"My sister was visiting from Colorado and wanted a real fish meal and raw oysters on the half shell and having been a customer of The Fish Store for many years and having dined there I thought of them right away. The oysters were very fresh but we had to ask for horseradish in addition to the seafood sauce. They were very accommodating as my sister wanted mahi mahi substituted for swordfish in the mango salsa dish which she enjoyed. My pepper crusted tuna was just seared enough for me as I like it on the rare side with smooth mashed potatoes and tasty creamed spinach. The presentation was gorgeous with the tuna sliced and fanned across the plate from the cloud like mashed potatoes and little...
Address
Alex
Friendly staff. Great food. A hidden gem! Happy to have found this place
Menu - 35 options
All prices are estimates.
Crab Cake
A crisp, golden crab cake with tender crab meat, seasoned perfectly for a delightful taste of the sea.
Mahi-Mahi
Grilled Mahi Mahi served with tropical mango salsa, lime-infused rice, and steamed seasonal vegetables.
Crab Cakes
Savory and golden crab cakes, crisp outside with tender, sweet crab meat inside, served with a zesty remoulade.
Clam Strips
Breaded and crispy fried clam strips served with zesty tartar sauce and lemon wedge.
Sea Scallops
Tender sea scallops, seared to perfection, served with a light lemon butter sauce.
Shrimp Scampi
Succulent shrimp sautéed in garlic butter sauce served over a bed of pasta with a hint of lemon and parsley.
Buffalo Shrimp
Crispy shrimp tossed in spicy buffalo sauce, served with a cooling side of celery and creamy ranch dip.
Shrimp Cocktail
Chilled shrimp served with zesty cocktail sauce and a hint of lemon.
Zucchini Sticks
Crispy and golden zucchini sticks served with a tangy dipping sauce for a delightful appetizer experience.
Reviews
Robert
This restaurant serves the best lobster tails in town! They also offer sushi-grade fresh fish and more. That's why I'm giving it a 5-star rating.
Laurel
I really love this place. Small and quaint. No yelling to be heard like in a big chain restaurant. They were very happy to make me a fish cake appetizer because I cannot have shellfish. Everything I have ever ordered there has been fantastic. Get there early or be prepared to wait for a table but you won 't be disappointed its worth it.
Paula
My sister was visiting from Colorado and wanted a real fish meal and raw oysters on the half shell and having been a customer of The Fish Store for many years and having dined there I thought of them right away. The oysters were very fresh but we had to ask for horseradish in addition to the seafood sauce. They were very accommodating as my sister wanted mahi mahi substituted for swordfish in the mango salsa dish which she enjoyed. My pepper crusted tuna was just seared enough for me as I like it on the rare side with smooth mashed potatoes and tasty creamed spinach. The presentation was gorgeous with the tuna sliced and fanned across the plate from the cloud like mashed potatoes and little...
Categories
-
Fish Delight in our exquisite fish dishes, crafted from the freshest catch of the day. From grilled favorites to savory stews, our menu celebrates the ocean's bounty with flavors to satisfy every palate.
-
Salad A delightful assortment of vibrant salads, featuring fresh greens, seasonal vegetables, and savory toppings, drizzled with our signature dressings for a refreshing and wholesome meal experience.
-
Lunch Satisfy your midday cravings with our delicious lunch menu. From fresh salads and hearty sandwiches to savory soups and vibrant bowls, each dish is crafted to give you the perfect midday boost.
-
Seafood Dive into the freshest catches of the sea with our seafood selection, featuring exquisite dishes prepared with high-quality fish and shellfish. Savor the flavors of the ocean in every bite!
Amenities
-
Lunch
-
Dinner
