Showfish - Menu

32 Star Island RoadNY 119545271, MONTAUK, United States

🛍 Wine, Fish, Seafood, American

4.5 💬 375 Reviews

Phone: +16316683133

Address: 32 Star Island RoadNY 119545271, MONTAUK, United States

City: MONTAUK

Dishes: 22

Reviews: 375

Website: https://showfishmtk.com/

"Location is beautiful but the food wasn’t as impressive. It was good, but not great. My scallops were cooked perfectly but the corn peas base seemed hard dry. My husband described the lobster tagliatelle, one of their specialties, as “average”. The menu is limited. We expected more seafood options with a name like Showfish. Service was subpar. They were too eager to clear the table even though we had an early reservation, it was out of season, they weren’t particularly busy. A dozen clams on the half shell came without a seafood fork. When one was requested, they first tried to substitute an espresso spoon. Really"


Address

Show Map

User User

Great restaurant, on food, decor, ambiance and service. Add to that a beautiful water view, plenty of outdoor tables and easy parking... we will definitely be back! Btw, the lobster rolls here are FANTASTIC

Menu - 22 options

All prices are estimates.

Reviews

User
User

The outdoor bartender was dismissive and not very friendly as she wanted to be done with her shift as we arrived having been told by staff to wait there. Other than that, the staff were friendly and the food was very good. The atmosphere was beautiful. We were seated inside with the patio doors open facing the water. Absolutely beautiful setting


User
User

I did not realize that Showfish is located in the Gurney's... can't say I would have booked it if I had known this as the resort is pretty meh to me. The restaurant is located on the water, has a fun vibe and a good menu. I thought the food was good, but I wouldn't make the trip out just to eat here. There was an engagement or wedding party in the private room, but they only had half of the space the rest had regular diners and all the doors were open so we had to listen to their DJ vs. the restaurant music. The other drawback was the wine selection, which was nothing to rave about


User
User

Location is beautiful but the food wasn’t as impressive. It was good, but not great. My scallops were cooked perfectly but the corn peas base seemed hard dry. My husband described the lobster tagliatelle, one of their specialties, as “average”. The menu is limited. We expected more seafood options with a name like Showfish. Service was subpar. They were too eager to clear the table even though we had an early reservation, it was out of season, they weren’t particularly busy. A dozen clams on the half shell came without a seafood fork. When one was requested, they first tried to substitute an espresso spoon. Really

Categories

  • Wine A curated selection of fine wines from around the world, offering rich reds, crisp whites, and elegant rosés to pair perfectly with your meal. Savor each bottle's unique aroma, flavor, and complexity.
  • Fish Delight in our exquisite fish dishes, crafted from the freshest catch of the day. From grilled favorites to savory stews, our menu celebrates the ocean's bounty with flavors to satisfy every palate.
  • Seafood Dive into the freshest catches of the sea with our seafood selection, featuring exquisite dishes prepared with high-quality fish and shellfish. Savor the flavors of the ocean in every bite!
  • American Enjoy classic American flavors with our diverse menu, featuring juicy burgers, crispy fried chicken, hearty BBQ ribs, and fresh salads. Indulge in timeless comfort with each bite, crafted to satisfy all tastes.

Amenities

  • View
  • Beer
  • Wine
  • Amex

Similar Restaurants