Johnny's Italian Steakhouse Middleton

8390 Market StreetWI 53562, Middleton, United States

🛍 Wine, Steak, Seafood, Italian

4.5 💬 370 Reviews

Phone: +16088564040,+16088313705

Address: 8390 Market StreetWI 53562, Middleton, United States

City: Middleton

Dishes: 35

Reviews: 370

Website: http://www.johnnysitaliansteakhouse.com/

"I ordered the filet mignon, but it was an end cut full of tendons. I had it replaced with what seemed to be a sirloin cut, but I didn't end up eating the meal. The server was young and friendly, but didn't know how to open a bottle of wine. This was the worst dining experience I've had at this restaurant in many visits. I won't be returning."


Address

Show Map

Coleman Coleman

The food and atmosphere are excellent, as is the service

Menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates.

Reviews

User
User

The food was delicious and we were impressed with the restaurant's adherence to social distancing guidelines and cleanliness. We had a great dining experience and look forward to returning soon.


User
User

The meal at Johnny's was exceptional and well worth the price. We had a fantastic time and enjoyed everything from the appetizer, salad, bread, steak to dessert. Our server was friendly and attentive, making it a top-notch dining experience.


User
User

I ordered the filet mignon, but it was an end cut full of tendons. I had it replaced with what seemed to be a sirloin cut, but I didn't end up eating the meal. The server was young and friendly, but didn't know how to open a bottle of wine. This was the worst dining experience I've had at this restaurant in many visits. I won't be returning.

Categories

  • Wine A curated selection of fine wines from around the world, offering rich reds, crisp whites, and elegant rosés to pair perfectly with your meal. Savor each bottle's unique aroma, flavor, and complexity.
  • Steak Savor prime cuts of juicy, tender steaks, expertly grilled to perfection. Each bite offers a burst of flavor, served with classic sides and delectable sauces to enhance your dining experience.
  • Seafood Dive into the freshest catches of the sea with our seafood selection, featuring exquisite dishes prepared with high-quality fish and shellfish. Savor the flavors of the ocean in every bite!
  • Italian Savor the rich and diverse flavors of Italy with our menu, offering classic pasta, savory risottos, and traditional meat and seafood dishes, all crafted with authentic ingredients and passion. Buon appetito!

Amenities

  • Beer
  • Wine
  • Menu
  • Banquet

Similar Restaurants

Eno Vino West Side

Eno Vino West Side

601 Junction RoadWI 53717, Madison, United States

Wine • Tapas • Steak • Seafood


"I was really looking forward to dining at Eno Vino for our anniversary. I love the ambience and the sophisticated feel of the place. However, things did not go as planned. First, it was COLD where we sat. And I’m hardly ever cold! It felt like we sitting under an air conditioner vent. Second, I started not to feel well while eating the truffle fries. The fries tasted great, but possibly were too rich for me. Or maybe it had nothing to do with the fries. Anyway, now I can say that the bathroom is as attractive as the rest of the establishment. Thirdly, there was a gentleman seated with several friends at a table near us when arrived who was VERY loud. He didn’t just laugh loud, he talked loud. We didn’t think he was inebriated, he was just LOUD! We discussed moving, but you could hear him all over the restaurant, so I don’t think it would have mattered. This, of course, wasn’t the restaurant’s fault, but it added to our discontent In all fairness, the waiter was wonderful! We mentioned being cold and he said he would talk to management. He answered all our questions and was meticulous about checking on us and asking if we were ready for the next course. And when I told him we would like our food boxed because I didn’t feel well, he was right on it and had our bill ready when he brought out the boxes. My husband had a few bites of the center cut filet and said it was delicious (and that is high praise from him because he is particular about his steak). The only other comment I have is that three small plates and two sodas cost over They are upfront about it, but are charging a COVID fee of which contributed to the expense. I’d like to say, “We’ll be back”, but the prices may keep us away."