Mckay's Public House

Phone: +12072882002

Address: 231 Main St, Bar Harbor, United States

Dishes: 35

Reviews: 343

Website: https://www.mckayspublichouse.com/

"Do not waste your money! This was the worst dining experience we have had in a long time! The waiter had zero personality and seemed to be annoyed at everything we asked/requested. We got our salad and appetizer even before the drinks came out!! The food came out way too quickly- seemed like we were at a fast food restaurant and they just wanted us out to turn the table. It was my husband’s birthday and we bought a nice bottle of wine but felt like we couldn’t enjoy it due to the fast pace of the food coming out! There is no way the food was cooked to order- it had to have been pre-cooked. Everything we ordered was bland and just ok- but very pricey! For example, the 1/2 chicken dinner was...

Address

OpenTable

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Wonderful meal. The risotto was fantastic. Lovely setting as well.

View More Reviews

Menu - 35 options

All prices are estimates.

Caesar

Crispy romaine, Parmesan, and Caesar dressing topped with crunchy croutons.

Risotto

Creamy risotto with Arborio rice, cooked to perfection, featuring a rich blend of Parmesan cheese and sautéed seasonal mushrooms.

Cheesecake

A creamy, rich dessert with a buttery crust and a smooth, tangy finish.

Mac Cheese

Creamy, gooey macaroni with rich, melted cheese, topped with a crispy breadcrumb crust for the ultimate comfort food experience.

Beet Salad

Beet Salad: A vibrant mix of roasted beets, fresh greens, tangy goat cheese, and a light vinaigrette dressing.

Fish Chips

Crispy battered fish with golden fries, served with tartar sauce and a lemon wedge.

Lobster Roll

Fresh lobster meat tossed in light mayo, nestled in a grilled buttery roll, topped with a hint of lemon and chives.

Caesar Salad

Crisp romaine lettuce, creamy Caesar dressing, parmesan cheese, and crunchy croutons.

Cheeseburger

Juicy beef patty, melted cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles, and special sauce, all stacked in a toasted bun.

Filet Mignon

Tender and succulent beef filet, perfectly grilled for a melt-in-your-mouth experience.

Shrimp Scampi

Succulent shrimp sautéed in garlic butter sauce served over a bed of pasta with a hint of lemon and parsley.

Kids Cheeseburger

A classic cheeseburger with a juicy beef patty, melted cheese, and a soft bun, sized perfectly for kids.

Impossible Burger

A plant-based burger patty that mimics the taste and texture of beef, served with fresh toppings and a choice of bun.

Reviews

Caroline

★ ★ ★ ★

Service was way too fast. We didn't have time to breathe between services, we felt like we had to eat as fast as possible so more customer would be able to have dinner there. We had the lobster meal. 50$ each. Nothing or almost nothing on the side. We actually went out and had dinner elsewhere after our 200$ meal. It was tasty though and high quality meal. Just not enough and waaayyy to fast.

DPozLikesGoodFood

★ ★ ★

There were 4 of us. We got Caesar Salad that was very good. We had the 1/2 herb roasted chicken that was actually the size of the Cornish Game Hen and, it was a little dry. The beef short ribs that was good. The serving has some roasted vegetables and mash potatoes stacked with the short rib meat on it. I was crazy about the way it was served but I did think it was good. We had a cheeseburger burger and fries and the Curried Vegetable dinner. Both were good, but not great. The service was fast, maybe a little too fast.

KimR

★

Do not waste your money! This was the worst dining experience we have had in a long time! The waiter had zero personality and seemed to be annoyed at everything we asked/requested. We got our salad and appetizer even before the drinks came out!! The food came out way too quickly- seemed like we were at a fast food restaurant and they just wanted us out to turn the table. It was my husband’s birthday and we bought a nice bottle of wine but felt like we couldn’t enjoy it due to the fast pace of the food coming out! There is no way the food was cooked to order- it had to have been pre-cooked. Everything we ordered was bland and just ok- but very pricey! For example, the 1/2 chicken dinner was m...

Amenities

Similar Restaurants

Reading Room At The Harbor Inn

➤ 1 Newport Dr.ME 04609, Bar Harbor, United States

Wine • Meat • Seafood • Chicken

"Excellent food and service, beautiful presentation of the dishes. also, a lovely view from the restaurant."

Galyn's

➤ 17 Main StME 04609, Bar Harbor, United States

Bar • Coffee • Seafood • Vegetarian

"Best lobster I?ve ever had! Staff was kind and knowledgeable, and answered all of our questions about lobster and the area. We came here after Geddy?s was sort of a bust, but Galyn?s did not disappoint. And all things considered, it was probably the cheapest lobster dinner I?ve ever had too. We were lucky enough to get a table on the patio which was absolutely lovely. Very nice view of the harbor and park with lots of natural light. The lobster was cooked perfectly and easy to remove from the shell. We were told this was a female. The rice and broccolini were also delicious."

Reading Room Restaurant at The Bar Harbor Inn

➤ 1 Newport Dr. Bar Harbor, ME 04609, United States

Steak • Hotels • Venues • Coffee

"HORRIBLE. Service at the bar was slow and disinterested. The unpadded wood chairs were both uncomfortable and incongruous with the elegant room. Once seated with a menu, I noted the absence of their famous lobster stew. They were known for this stew with the lobster shaped puff pastry atop, and this should have tipped me off the kitchen skill had plummeted. I ordered the lobster (chowder? bisque to be followed by the lobster dinner. The bisque arrived, and other than looking a little dark, was nicely presented with a small portion of lobster. The lobster meat was tender and warm. BUT the bisque was ghastly. It had all the flavor of flour and warm water. It wasn 't just bland; it was not food but instead paste typically given to children. Upon receiving this dish I proceeded to do something I have never done before: I called over the waiter and advised him this was not to my liking; to cancel the entrée; and charge me only for the porridge if I were required to pay since I ate the piece of lobster (with the remainder of the gruel left undisturbed in the bowl . Without any inquiry over my dissatisfaction, I was presented with a bill for the bilge. I paid and departed without so much as an inquiry or expression of concern. The inescapable conclusion is that the establishment is fully aware its fare is wholly inesculent; otherwise, general curiosity alone would have warranted what seems to be out of order or is there something else I might bring you, or I 'm so sorry our food has sickened you. Certainly the pandemic staff shortage has hobbled the kitchen. But there are plenty of canned and institutional bisques that are at least palatable. Who hasn 't eaten on an airplane. But this was far worse than airline food. The combination of poor food and unprofessional management compels dining elsewhere in Bar Harbor. That the restaurant would serve this compels avoiding anything from its kitchen. Look elsewhere for now."

Havana

➤ 318 Main St Bar Harbor, ME 04609-1637, 04609-1648, United States

Soup • Salad • Seafood • Vegetarian

"Havana's team has healed an incredible evening-dinner experience. We made our reservation a few weeks in advance, and we are very happy that we are. We included that we celebrated our honeymoon in the online booking, and the hostess knew that and congratulated us at check-in! The group behind us also had no reservation and was told that they were able to come back and sit at 20:30. Our table was in a beautiful corner of the restaurant, and they contain a map of all the staff who congratulate us on our honeymoon!!! The first treat and the bread that was brought to us were so beautiful. The apricot shop was a nice touch, and the bread plate and accompanying spreads were delicious. We wanted the recipe for the black bean spread and the spicy chili oil and butter were also incredible. The wine book is incomparable, we were clearly above our minds in the 70 pages, but also with the combination of participants we wanted to order. The sommelier heard our demand for red, but pairing with seafood and lambcuffs and recommended 2 special bottles. We chose one of his recommendations and it was really perfect for soups and 2 ducks. While we enjoyed the seafood cats, we cannot say enough amazing things about the cured pumpkin soup! We know we never reach his size, but we want to try to make it ourselves. It was creamy and tasty and had only the perfect mix of spices. On the Entrees both were the perfect portions that we even went a few into a container. The seafood paella had so much seafood from as many varieties as the chorizo! One of the best paellas we have ever had. And the lamb was buttery and almost melted in our mouth. Cooked perfectly and we rarely took the recommendation of the head of Medium. Dessert the blueberry bread pudding was complete perfection. We brought the pumpkin back with us."

Cafe This Way

➤ 14 Mt Desert St, Bar Harbor, USA, 04609, United States

Coffee • Spanish • European • American

"Great atmosphere and attentive staff, good coffee, and very limited vegan options. A bit pricey but satisfying portions; not outside expectations in any tourist town. Vegetarian options: Only 2 vegan options and both are tofu. The addition of ployes or other non-soy vegan pancake and vegan butter to the menu would definitely be welcome and would greatly increase the chance of me recommending them to other vegans as I am mildly allergic to soy"